NWC youth 16-18 withdraw from BARLA

Page 1 of 7 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7  Next

View previous topic View next topic Go down

NWC youth 16-18 withdraw from BARLA

Post by Lee Marchant on Sun Jan 18, 2009 6:50 am

ALL YOUTH & JUNIOR NORTH WEST COUNTIES CLUBS PLEASE SEE THE LETTER SENT FROM HILARY STEEL TO BARLA

MILTON METALS LTD, NORTH WEST COUNTIES YOUTH 16 – 18 AMATEUR RUGBY LEAGUE


16 January 2009

Mr N Hollingsworth
BARLA Secretary
West Yorkshire House
4 New North Parade
HUDDERSFIELD
HD1 5JP

Dear Nigel

Membership of BARLA – rule 4.14

At a recent Management meeting of this League, the members discussed both full membership and associate membership of BARLA.

At the meeting which both Spen Allison and Carole Land attended last
year, the delegates voted by a majority not to be members of BARLA for
the season 2008 – 09. .

Since then, nothing has changed and the committee feels that it must
exercise its rights to act on behalf of the delegates as mandated, to
run this league for the better benefits of all concerned.

This means that for the purpose of clarity, the North West Counties
Youth 16 – 18 ARL will no longer be either full members or associate
members of BARLA.

As League Secretary I hereby give this notice officially and wish to
inform you all that this league will be formally requesting to join the
Other Leagues section of the Community Board.

Kindly, therefore, accept this formal letter as confirmation of this League’s intent to withdraw from BARLA.

Yours sincerely



Hilary Steel
Chair/Secretary

Lee Marchant
Admin
Admin

Number of posts: 180
Age: 43
Location: Doncaster
Registration date: 2008-09-09

View user profile http://barla.forumotion.net

Back to top Go down

Re: NWC youth 16-18 withdraw from BARLA

Post by Sam Armstrong on Sun Jan 18, 2009 9:20 am

The two sister youth/junior leagues in the North West Counties catchment areas are fully aware of the letter and the issue has already also been discussed with the clubs forming the 13-15's League to see what action they wish to take. Surely, or should I say hopefully, those in charge will finally wake up and see the damage that is being done by the Board's current negative stance and seeming complete apathy towards the youth/junior game.

These players are the future of BARLA and their leaving at younger age groups will have a whole generation growing up wondering, when they've managed from the age of under 7 to 18 years to survive without it, what benefits there are to being in the Association. scratch

Sam Armstrong
Admin
Admin

Number of posts: 167
Age: 50
Location: One step away from insanity!!
Registration date: 2009-01-18

View user profile http://www.nwc13-15arl.co.uk

Back to top Go down

NWC 16-18s leave BARLA

Post by samsung on Sun Jan 18, 2009 2:25 pm

Good to see democracy reigning supreme in the NWC 16-18s league under the leadership of the Chairperson!!

If the clubs vote to become Associate members - it doesn't follow that the clubs want to pull out of BARLA altogether.

Have the clubs been informed of this latest move by the Chairperson - who always seems to imagine that she is "mandated" to do what the hell she wants to do. Perhaps the clubs should be sent the minutes of the last Management Meeting to see how this very serious decision came about. Perhaps, also, it should be made clear to the clubs BEFORE the next AGM what the "mandate" she has actually includes.

samsung
Junior player
Junior player

Number of posts: 18
Registration date: 2009-01-18

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: NWC youth 16-18 withdraw from BARLA

Post by Sam Armstrong on Sun Jan 18, 2009 5:08 pm

Sorry to spoil your case with actual facts Samsung but if you'd bothered to check before you posted you'd have answered most of your own questions and possibly avoided making yourself look rather silly.

The September 08 minutes covering the meeting where the vote took place ARE there in the public domain for all to see in the Minutes section of their website at www.nwcyouth16-18.co.uk and I quote ..
Recent Discussion with BARLA Board Members
As a result of the previous discussion, a proposal from Hindley was made, seconded Thatto Heath Crusaders “that this league should not re-join BARLA this season”. The vote was carried, 15 voting members, 11 for the proposal and 4 against. The delegates were reminded that this subject has been under discussion for the last three meetings and that now the management can continue to manage the league in the best way possible for the teams and players – as mandated many months ago
So to answer your individual statements
samsung wrote:Good to see democracy reigning supreme in the NWC 16-18s league under the leadership of the Chairperson!!
By Democracy do you mean the the Chairperson giving every club the right to vote on the proposal?? Erm ... well yes they did.
samsung wrote:If the clubs vote to become Associate members - it doesn't follow that the clubs want to pull out of BARLA altogether.
According to the above underlined section of the minutes thats EXACTLY what they voted for.
samsung wrote:Perhaps the clubs should be sent the minutes of the last Management Meeting to see how this very serious decision came about. Perhaps, also, it should be made clear to the clubs BEFORE the next AGM what the "mandate" she has actually includes.
The minutes are there for EVERYONE to see ... no secrecy ... and the mandate was clearly that the NWC 16-18's League "should not rejoin BARLA".

Sam Armstrong
Admin
Admin

Number of posts: 167
Age: 50
Location: One step away from insanity!!
Registration date: 2009-01-18

View user profile http://www.nwc13-15arl.co.uk

Back to top Go down

Re: NWC youth 16-18 withdraw from BARLA

Post by samsung on Mon Jan 19, 2009 1:43 am

The vote taken at the September meeting referred to Associate membership - not full withdrawal - or so most of the teams thought.

Full withdrawal is completely different - so don't patronise me or other members of BARLA.

If you were to read my post - I suggested that clubs see the minutes of the MANAGEMENT meeting, where the committee decided to use your "mandate". Not the minutes of the Monthly meeting that are on the website. I do presume that the committee discussed this decision at great length before it was announced at a recent BARLA meeting.

The broad scope of the word "mandate" should be treated a little differently when you are talking of such an action. Mandates normally refer to the "general" running of a league in the everyday sense of things.

I'm not suggesting that the outcome wouldn't have been the same at some point now or in the future - but it shouldn't be presented to the clubs that have teams in your league that the decision has been made by the committee or individuals.

samsung
Junior player
Junior player

Number of posts: 18
Registration date: 2009-01-18

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: NWC youth 16-18 withdraw from BARLA

Post by Sam Armstrong on Mon Jan 19, 2009 3:30 am

samsung wrote:... don't patronise me or other members of BARLA.
Firstly, let me say I didn't "patronise" you (where the other members of BARLA come into it I don't know) .... I in fact merely highlighted and gave you the facts to contradict the incorrect statements you made!!

Like many small committees consisting basically of 2 or 3 active members, I believe that the 16-18's don't keep minutes of their Management Meetings, indeed we at the 13-15's, who are fortunate to have 9 active team members meet prior to our club's meeting to discuss pressing issues and these are invariably then put into the public domain as they are raised & discussed with the whole floor and only then publicly minuted. Why do the work twice and create seperate minutes when, in essence, they are the same???

The vote, minuted (and approved as correct at the next meeting) was, as highlighted in my previous post, “that this league should not re-join BARLA this season” and was proposed by one club, seconded by another and then voted on democratically.

No individual Club has been asked to leave BARLA merely that the fixture organising Regional League (who recognise that as Associate Members they receive no correspondence, have no input in development of the game and are not allowed to attend meetings etc) be allowed to, instead, ally themselves with what they feel is a more pro-active and supportive organisation and come under their umbrella for the benefit of their clubs and players.

Your concern over the use of the word mandate is also questionable. Every year at the League's AGM each position on the Committee is able to be contested, and personnel are voted in as the League's representatives not only with your definition of a "mandate" for the
"general" running of a league in the everyday sense of things.
which they do, but more specifically, a mandate also means the authority granted by an electorate to act as it's representative which is exactly what Hilary has done following the vote.

How the above fits into your statement
.. but it shouldn't be presented to the clubs that have teams in your league that the decision has been made by the committee or individuals
when it was minuted that it was a club proposed and not a committee or individual action is, frankly, beyond me.

Please feel free to inform us what you believe the youth & junior Regional League's gain from remaining as members of BARLA as, the growing consensus i our age-groups, seems to be "nothing" other than not upsetting the apple cart for our seemingly open-age obsessed Association! I say again, these players are the future of our sport .... show an interest before it is too late and this once great Association becomes a victim of it's own apathy to the youth of today.

Sam Armstrong
Admin
Admin

Number of posts: 167
Age: 50
Location: One step away from insanity!!
Registration date: 2009-01-18

View user profile http://www.nwc13-15arl.co.uk

Back to top Go down

Re: NWC youth 16-18 withdraw from BARLA

Post by Lee Marchant on Mon Jan 19, 2009 3:43 am

Sam Armstrong wrote:The two sister youth/junior leagues in the North West Counties catchment areas are fully aware of the letter and the issue has already also been discussed with the clubs forming the 13-15's League to see what action they wish to take. Surely, or should I say hopefully, those in charge will finally wake up and see the damage that is being done by the Board's current negative stance and seeming complete apathy towards the youth/junior game.

These players are the future of BARLA and their leaving at younger age groups will have a whole generation growing up wondering, when they've managed from the age of under 7 to 18 years to survive without it, what benefits there are to being in the Association. scratch

Sam,

The whole point of this forum, is to encourage constructive dialogue,

there is a page here , specifically for airing concerns. Can I suggest you, compose a post, outlining why you think damage is being done, why you feel there is a negative stance and complete apathy, and maybe you could suggest some reasonable ideas to address the issues as you see them...

Lee Marchant
Admin
Admin

Number of posts: 180
Age: 43
Location: Doncaster
Registration date: 2008-09-09

View user profile http://barla.forumotion.net

Back to top Go down

Re: NWC youth 16-18 withdraw from BARLA

Post by Sam Armstrong on Mon Jan 19, 2009 3:55 am

Have the clubs been informed of this latest move by the Chairperson - who always seems to imagine that she is "mandated" to do what the hell she wants to do.
I'm sorry ... was that "constructive dialogue"??
The Leagues did put their questions and concerns to the board and, indeed, the lack of response from the Board was quoted as one of the reasons for leaving that a former Board member cited in her resignation letter.

Sam Armstrong
Admin
Admin

Number of posts: 167
Age: 50
Location: One step away from insanity!!
Registration date: 2009-01-18

View user profile http://www.nwc13-15arl.co.uk

Back to top Go down

Re: NWC youth 16-18 withdraw from BARLA

Post by Lee Marchant on Mon Jan 19, 2009 4:30 am

Sam Armstrong wrote:
Have the clubs been informed of this latest move by the Chairperson - who always seems to imagine that she is "mandated" to do what the hell she wants to do.
I'm sorry ... was that "constructive dialogue"??
The Leagues did put their questions and concerns to the board and, indeed, the lack of response from the Board was quoted as one of the reasons for leaving that a former Board member cited in her resignation letter.

Yep, point taken and I agree that it was an unnecessary comment, and PM has been sent to the poster,

However, your general demeanour on this thread (and the less than courteous pm I received) is not in keeping with the spirit with which this forum was set up.

If your sole intent is to come on here and to be antagonistic, without following simple courtesies, then the forum can do without you.

I have no idea of the historical arguments and differences between different leagues and memberships, so to that extent, everyone has a clean slate on this forum as I have no axe to grind with anyone.

However, as this message board is OFFICIALLY tied to BARLA, all users have to treat what they post with respect, and behaviour which may be tollerated on independant forums will not be allowed on here for obvious reasons.

The etiquette standards required are fully listed in the forum rules, and I will ensure they are adhered to.

anyway, can we get back to the topic please...

Lee Marchant
Admin
Admin

Number of posts: 180
Age: 43
Location: Doncaster
Registration date: 2008-09-09

View user profile http://barla.forumotion.net

Back to top Go down

Re: NWC youth 16-18 withdraw from BARLA

Post by Sam Armstrong on Mon Jan 19, 2009 5:43 am

I apologise if my pm was seemingly taken out of context, it was merely frustration at having spent 30 mins composing and typing only to lose everything but it was a genuine question sent in a frustrated yet lighthearted manner and not meant to cause offence. Embarassed

As for getting back to being on topic .... we were!!! The discussion and subsequent posts were about the 16-18's voting to leave scratch

Sam Armstrong
Admin
Admin

Number of posts: 167
Age: 50
Location: One step away from insanity!!
Registration date: 2009-01-18

View user profile http://www.nwc13-15arl.co.uk

Back to top Go down

Re: NWC youth 16-18 withdraw from BARLA

Post by Steve Manning on Mon Jan 19, 2009 1:40 pm

THIS IS THE EMAIL THAT LOL LOWE THE CHAIRMAN OF WIGAN ST JUDES
SENT TO HILARY STEEL FOLLOWING THE 16-18'S DECISION FOR WITHDRAWAL FROM
BARLA


SENT : SUNDAY, JANUARY 18, 2009 6:18 PM

SUBJECT : WITHDRAWAL FROM BARLA


---

DEAR
MISS STEEL

ST JUDES ARLFC REMAINS FULL MEMBERS OF BARLA AT ALL AGES AND
YOUR MEMBERS VOTED TO BE ASSOCIATE MEMBERS OF BARLA AS YOU AND YOUR CRONIES SEEM TO DIFFER FROM WHAT WAS AGREED YOUR LEAGUE WILL NOT BE AFFORDED THE USE OF OUR CLUB FOR YOUR MEETINGS"


LOL LOWE

CHAIRMAN

Steve Manning
BARLA PRO and Media Manager
BARLA PRO and Media Manager

Number of posts: 41
Registration date: 2009-01-19

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: NWC youth 16-18 withdraw from BARLA

Post by Sam Armstrong on Mon Jan 19, 2009 10:21 pm

Everyone has the right to decide whether they agree or disagree with the League's decision but agree or not it was democratically voted for and recorded as such.

Because the vote didn't go your way is no excuse for petulance and petty personal name calling. However, at the end of the day, I'm quite sure there are plenty of other clubs who will appreciate the bar takings of 70/80 people on a usually quiet Wednesday night .... surely this is simply cutting off your nose to spite your face in these economically difficult times??

Sam Armstrong
Admin
Admin

Number of posts: 167
Age: 50
Location: One step away from insanity!!
Registration date: 2009-01-18

View user profile http://www.nwc13-15arl.co.uk

Back to top Go down

Re: NWC youth 16-18 withdraw from BARLA

Post by Steve Manning on Tue Jan 20, 2009 1:28 am

ATTENTION THE VIEWS OF LOL LOWE

THE VIEWS OF LOL LOWE THE CHAIRMAN OF WIGAN ST JUDES IN RELATION TO THE EMAIL SENT TO HILARY STEEL FOLLOWING THE WITHDRAWAL OF THE 16-18 NORTH WEST COUNTIES LEAGUE FROM BARLA ARE LOL LOWE’S OWN PERSONAL VIEWS


STEVE MANNING

BARLA PRO & MEDIA MANAGER

Steve Manning
BARLA PRO and Media Manager
BARLA PRO and Media Manager

Number of posts: 41
Registration date: 2009-01-19

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: NWC youth 16-18 withdraw from BARLA

Post by Big Bad Bri on Tue Jan 20, 2009 2:06 am

I wasn't at the meeting, but have spoken to people that were there

they thought that they were voting to keep the status quo, and to remain associate.

I'm not saying you wouldn't have got the decison you wanted, but it looks like people were duped into voting for something that wasn't clearly explained to them.

If Hillary and yourself carry on like this in the future, you may find yourselfs without much support. People don't like having the wool pulled over their eyes

Big Bad Bri
Junior player
Junior player

Number of posts: 33
Registration date: 2009-01-18

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: NWC youth 16-18 withdraw from BARLA

Post by pandasdad on Tue Jan 20, 2009 10:43 am

Having been at the NWC meeting last Wednesday, I was surprised by the withdrawal from BARLA on the following Sunday. That's not to say, though, that I'm against it.

The criticism of BARLA for some years now has been that it has been totally Open Age oriented and while there have been Junior/Youth members of the Board of Management, they have had little or no involvement with Junior/Youth matters outside of that role. That may or may not be the case now, but in view of the fact that senior NWC reps like Hilary and Sam appear to believe it to be so, means that, at the very least, communication has been lacking. In particular, looking back on the minutes of the meeting in which Hilary was given a mandate by the clubs, there were numerous examples of correspondence to BARLA Management Board members going unanswered and not even a note of explanation or apology. Hardly a sign of interest and encouragement to those who dedicate many hours to the development of the game to the benefit of both Junior/Youth and Open Age.

Even this new forum, which should be recognised as a step forward, seems to ignore the Youth and Junior Leagues in its very layout.

The U16s of the club to which I belong played in a National Cup match on Sunday and while the results have been posted on this forum, the BARLA website still shows the last matches having been played in May 2008, the fixtures for this year never having been shown on the site at all, so far. A relatively simple issue to rectify, but from what I can gather, a symptom of the malaise which appears to be at the core of the complaints about the relationship of BARLA and its erstwhile members.

It strikes me that it's time that some of the people involved forgot about grand titles and got around the table, at a neutral and central venue, to discuss the issues openly, perhaps under the scrutiny of a Chairperson who has no direct involvement. What's Richard Lewis doing next weekend?

pandasdad
Junior player
Junior player

Number of posts: 48
Registration date: 2009-01-20

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Page 1 of 7 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7  Next

View previous topic View next topic Back to top


Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum